(Photo Credits: Kathy Hutchins from Shutterstock)
Every gay guy has had at least one celebrity fantasy. Maybe it was the first time you saw a shirtless movie star on screen or that TV heartthrob who made you question everything. One gay man online asked, “If you had the chance to fuck one celebrity (now or in their prime), who would you pick?” The responses poured in—and we’ve rounded up some of the hottest (and most relatable) ones.
One commenter kept it short and sweet: “Jake Gyllenhaal, that is all.” From Donnie Darko to his rougher roles in Nightcrawler and Southpaw, Jake’s blend of boy-next-door charm and intense acting chops definitely fuels a few bedroom daydreams.
Then there’s Tom Welling, the ultimate crush for many gay millennials. Known best for playing Clark Kent in Smallville, Welling’s chiseled jawline and tall, dark, and handsome face made plenty of fans wish he’d crash into their backyard instead.
Chris Hemsworth came up multiple times, and we get it. Whether wielding Thor’s hammer in the Marvel Cinematic Universe or making us swoon with his beachy Australian vibe, Chris checks all the boxes.
Another fan favorite? David Boreanaz. “Angel” from Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Angel, or later as Agent Booth in Bones, Boreanaz brought dark, brooding, and sexy to an entire generation of viewers.
Henry Cavill is another leading man many gay men dream about. From his role as Superman to playing Geralt in The Witcher, Cavill’s muscular build, deep voice, and British accent are basically porn for the soul.
Another popular pick, Idris Elba, brings pure charisma and gravitas to every role—from Luther to The Wire to Fast & Furious. His presence is magnetic, and yes, the thirst is real.
Jonathan Bailey, known for Bridgerton, also had his name thrown into the ring. His mix of Regency-era sex appeal and real-life queerness makes him a fantasy that feels closer to home.
Matt Bomer also came up, and let’s face it, he’s a gay icon. Whether he’s charming the pants off viewers in White Collar, showing off his body in Magic Mike, or just being his ridiculously handsome self— Matt Bomer is that rare Hollywood beauty who looks just as flawless in a tux as he does shirtless on screen.
It’s not just about their bodies—it’s the way they move, talk, smolder, and command the screen. Fantasizing about celebrities is harmless fun.
So now, let’s hear from you, Adam4Adam blog readers: if you could fuck one celebrity, who would you pick? Was it someone you crushed on as a teen, or someone new who caught your eye on Netflix last week? Drop your fantasy picks in the comments—and feel free to name more than one!
Hands down, Joe Burrow, the QB for the Cincinnati Bengals. Hands almost down, Tom Holland, the “Spider Man” actor. Hands once down but long ago, Matt Damon (but now he’s old).
Matt Damon and you are both old. Dismissing him because he is old, dismisses yourself
nothing like good ole’ discrimination
Who says I’d be into me?
your imagination?
I know you’re just kidding/digging, but I’m 65, bald, OK built, fairly hairy, and pretty good looking. But my ideal type is ages 20s-40s, full head of hair, on the smoother side, cute/boyish look, athletic build. That’s why I said I wouldn’t be into me – I’m not my type LOL.
I’ll take your Matt Damon off your hands . . .(now).
You can have him now, no charge. But circa 1994 in “Good Will Hunting”…he’s all mine.
That’s EASY! John Krasinski!
Jesse Williams
Odell Beckham jr is the only one I desire. That dude is really hot and a very good athlete too.
He looks like he smells like old chicken grease.
Nicholas Galitzine is my movie star crush. This man has played some amazing roles such as a young naive individual all the way to a Prince living under the pressure of country expectations.
I have also had a crush on Tom Welling from Smallville when he was a young actor as well as when he was a hotter adult on Lucifer.
Jalen Hurts, Liam Hemsworth, Boris Kodjoe, James Franco, Justin Fields, Stephen Curry, Justin Bieber, Idris Elba, Dakota Prescott, Zachary Quinto, Ashton Kutcher, Edward Burns…and Don Rickles, for laughs.
I love you have various types. “Boris Kodjoe, James Franco and Idris Elba, Stephen Currie” yes.
Easy…. John Slattery, John O’Hurley, and John Hamm. I guess I have a thing for Johns
Jake Gylenhal
Jonathan Bailey
Adam Levine
I can’t watch Christian McCaffrey for too long because he is that hot. Zach Ertz, too. And from a long time ago, Jordy Nelson, who had such a cute smile. Someone mentioned Joe Burrow, who I also like, but mostly because he seems like a nice guy who doesn’t take himself seriously, and who probably doesn’t think he’s hot.
I mentioned Burrow because he’s just gorgeous.
Well my first and forever fantasy is Steve McQueen! Theses days jacob Elordi get me wet
I have to admit that I have no clue who most of the people mentioned in the comments are. I guess I was “old” while Matt Damon was still “young”. LOL My choice is Carl Weathers…professional football player turned actor.
Thinking about ordering pizza. Wondering if I should get it from joes or mulberry
Mandingo
Man of War
Rin Tin Tin for a three way with Lassie
Taylor Lautner
Shemeeka from that Tyler Perry show. That boy packin
Shemeeka has a vagina.
No vagina. This boy is hung!
Who?
Lisa Lawrence and Gia Darling in a threesome. With Greg Brady slurping up the snowball
Always had a thing for cartoon Aladdin, baggy pants with a vest and no shirt.
this was done before…
Keanu Reeves
Jon Hamm
Jake Gyllenhaal
Henry Cavill
Chris Pine
Chris Evans
Paul Rudd
in no particular order but I’d consider any marriage proposal from Keanu. Just saying (are you reading this?).
I like Paul Rudd too, he has an huge booty!
Okay, so call me an old fogey, but I had the pleasure of meeting Barry Manilow, back stage at a concert in 1986. He and I were both 6’5″ and our eyes met. I swear to God he was undressing me with those baby blues, while I was doing the same to him. It was just a passing glance and It wasn’t well known at the time that he was gay, so I really had no idea. Needless to say though, I fell in love on the spot and have fantasized about getting naked with him ever since.
German superstar tenor Jonas Kaufmann….:)
Brandon Flynn. He is so SEXY!
This will really date me, but the current actors just aren’t that appealing. In the 60s, there were stars like Paul Newman, Robert Redford, Robert Conrad, and Burt Reynolds. Today’s actors have neither the talent nor the charisma of their predecessors.
Billy Porter. I will bust some heavy nut in him!